Circumcision and Citizenship – by Wes McAdams


The difficulty of circumcision was one of many greatest points with which the early church wrestled. It’s laborious for Christians at present to know why circumcision was such a divisive situation. There are a number of causes we wrestle to know the importance of circumcision, but in addition a number of causes this first-century debate has a number of Twenty first-century relevance. 

After the Flood, God made a covenant, “By no means once more shall all flesh be minimize off by the waters of the flood, and by no means once more shall there be a flood to destroy the earth” (Genesis 9:11). Then God mentioned, “I’ve set my bow within the cloud, and it shall be an indication of the covenant between me and the earth” (Genesis 9:13). The rainbow serves as “an indication of the covenant.” 

God later makes use of the identical language about circumcision, “You shall be circumcised within the flesh of your foreskins, and it shall be an indication of the covenant between me and also you” (Genesis 17:11). In the identical method {that a} rainbow was a visible marker, token, or signal of God’s covenant with the entire world, circumcision was an indication of God’s covenant with Abraham and his descendants. 

A “token” or “signal” was a standard function of historic covenants, however it is usually commonplace in fashionable marriage ceremony ceremonies. By exchanging rings, the couple is giving each other an indication of their covenant. The rings mark the husband as belonging to the spouse, and the spouse as belonging to the husband. The rings remind these throughout the covenant, in addition to these on the surface, that guarantees have been made and should be saved. 

Equally, circumcision was a present God gave to Israel to mark them as belonging to him as his particular individuals. The males of the nation, as representatives of every household, carried round this token of the covenant in all places they went.

On a literal degree, circumcision was eradicating a chunk of flesh (foreskin). Nevertheless, it is also understood as a metaphor, regarding what God wished to do with the hearts of his individuals. It wasn’t merely the literal flesh that God wished circumcised, it was the guts of each Israelite. Moses mentioned:

“But the LORD set his coronary heart in love in your fathers and selected their offspring after them, you above all peoples, as you might be at the present time. Circumcise subsequently the foreskin of your coronary heart, and be now not cussed.” 

– Deuteronomy 10:15-16

In different phrases, circumcision ought to have been an outward signal of what was speculated to occur to the guts. The rebellious, sinful, and cussed flesh across the coronary heart needs to be metaphorically “minimize away” and eliminated. To be circumcised within the flesh however not within the coronary heart was primarily a lie, a sort of hypocrisy. Such individuals had been pretending to be God’s individuals. Jeremiah mentioned, “Behold, the times are coming, declares the LORD, when I’ll punish all those that are circumcised merely within the flesh” (Jeremiah 9:25).

Sadly, we generally tend to compartmentalize our lives: spiritual vs. secular, non secular vs. bodily. The signal of circumcision was speculated to be each non secular and bodily. Sadly, typically circumcision was merely exterior and bodily. God seen these individuals as being the identical as uncircumcised Gentiles (Jeremiah 9:26).

If you wish to perceive why circumcision was so controversial within the first-century church, think about how some nations take into consideration partitions, fences, borders, and bounds. There’s a nationalistic impulse to guard a nation’s lifestyle from outdoors affect. When the borders begin being blurred, many individuals change into anxious and defensive. 

After the Exile, the “nation of Israel” was not a spot on a map, they had been a diaspora (a dispersed individuals group). The boundary between the nation of Israel and the Gentiles was not on the bottom, however on their our bodies. Regardless the place he lived, the mark of circumcision was the mark that divided a Jew from the remainder of the world.

When you concentrate on circumcision, take into consideration different nationwide and ethnic symbols, indicators, and markers. This class may assist us perceive the nationalistic impulse to defend it. 

When the Gospel was proclaimed on Pentecost, there have been 3,000 who had been baptized in repentant religion (Acts 2). These individuals lived in varied locations and spoke a number of totally different languages. Nevertheless, the entire males had been (presumably) circumcised. These Jewish Christians didn’t see themselves as changing from “Judaism” to “Christianity.” They noticed themselves as pledging their loyalty and allegiance to Jesus, Israel’s Messiah, who had been killed and raised from the lifeless. 

For a few years, the church was made up solely of circumcised (Jewish) followers of Jesus. For them, following Jesus was not a change of faith, however a continuation of their nationwide and spiritual hope that YHWH would ship a Messiah to save lots of their individuals. They rightfully believed God had saved his guarantees to rescue and redeem the nation of Israel. 

So, after all, when the Good Information about God’s kingdom was preached to uncircumcised individuals, many insisted that these Gentiles be circumcised. In any case, in pledging their allegiance to Israel’s King, Gentiles had been primarily immigrating into the nation of Israel. They had been making an attempt to change into a part of the household and have a share in Israel’s future inheritance of “the world” (Romans 4:13).

Many Jewish Christians instructed Gentiles, “Except you might be circumcised in accordance with the customized of Moses, you can’t be saved” (Acts 15:1). This assertion was spiritual, however was additionally political and nationalistic. They had been (wrongly) claiming circumcision was essential to be a part of the dominion that God was saving from this current evil age. How on the planet, they thought, can somebody assume they’re part of God’s covenant individuals with out the signal of circumcision?

This debate is a minimum of a part of the underlying context of many books of the New Testomony. You may particularly see its prominence within the books of Acts, Galatians, and Ephesians. The books of Romans and Colossians have relevance for this dialog as properly.

It’s comprehensible why some circumcised Christians felt like Gentile inclusion throughout the kingdom was primarily an invasion of their nation. However this impulse, as comprehensible because it could be, was NOT in accordance the desire of our King. The reply from Jesus, given by means of the apostles, was that ALL faith-led, Spirit-filled, baptized followers of Jesus had equal standing within the true Israel. Each single Christian—on both aspect of the circumcision boundary—was thought of a full-fledged baby of Abraham. Paul wrote, “If you’re Christ’s, then you might be Abraham’s offspring, heirs in accordance with promise” (Galatians 3:29).

Uncircumcised believers had been now “fellow residents” (Ephesians 2:19). The “dividing wall” between circumcised and uncircumcised was torn down in Christ (Ephesians 2:14). When an individual was baptized, Jew or Gentile, male or feminine, slave or free, that individual was spiritually circumcised by Jesus (Colossians 2:11-15). The Holy Spirit—and his fruit—was now the true signal of the covenant. This was the proof that an individual’s coronary heart was really circumcised they usually belonged to the covenant individuals of God (Galatians 5:16-25).

I hope you may see that this debate is extremely related for Christians at present. It isn’t a lot about, “who’s going to heaven?” That wasn’t the query they had been asking. It’s way more related (and controversial) than that.

This debate teaches us to ask questions like these:

  • No matter the place you reside, to what nation/kingdom do you see your self belonging? 

  • Are there symbols, markers, tokens, or indicators that you just count on others to have to be able to embrace them in your tribe?

  • Who do you actually see as “fellow residents”? 

  • Are you serving to Jesus tear down the partitions and bounds that exist between brothers and sisters in Christ from totally different tribes, nations, and languages? 

I like you and God loves you,

Wes McAdams

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles